Let’s get Jonathan Pollard Out of Jail, byRabbi Asher Lopatin

Representative Barney Frank, a liberal Democrat close to the Obama administration, is circulating a letter through the House of Representatives calling for clemency for Jonathan Pollard. There is a lot we do not know about Pollard’s case, but what we do know is that his sentence – a plea bargain! – was way beyond anything anyone else has gotten for spying for an ally (Israel) and that even those who pushed for his harsh sentencing – such as Sec. of Defense Casper Weinberger – have expressed long ago that Pollard has been in for long enough. Even though Pollard violated American law, he acted out of devotion to Israel. We may all have to admit that there is a little bit of Pollard in any American – Jewish or gentile – who loves the State of Israel and is passionate about helping her survive against those who wish to destroy her. Yes, we all need to respect the laws of our country, and never put American lives at risk, as Pollard may have done. At the same time, we have to be understanding and sympathetic to what motivated Pollard, and we have to honestly feel for his passionate sacrificing of his life for the State of Israel.
My Representative in Chicago, Jan Schakowsky, who is on the House Select Intelligence Committee, has signed on to this letter. If you agree that 25 years is enough prison for Jonathan Pollard, and that it is important not to forget about someone who was acting to help Israel, then please call or email your Representative, and ask if they have signed on to the Barney Frank letter. Rep. Frank has said that if this letter gets enough signatures, he will present it to the president. This is an rare opportunity to make a difference – I hope if you feel it is the right thing that you just pick up the phone and call your Representative and let them know how you feel.
Right after all our prayers to change the world, we have a real opportunity for positive change. Let’s not squander it.
Rabbi Asher Lopatin

3 Responses to Let’s get Jonathan Pollard Out of Jail, byRabbi Asher Lopatin

  1. Phyllis Shapiro says:

    I think that without knowing the facts of the case, it is not a good idea to say that his sentence is too harsh. You write that Pollard “may have” put American lives in danger. What if, in fact, Pollard’s activities directly cost the lives of 5 or 6 American agents? Would a life sentecne be too harash? Would you then be willing to say that there is a “little bit of Pollard” in you?

  2. Concerned says:

    I am concerned that without knowing the facts you are so sure that Jonathan Pollard has served enough time.
    Presidents Clinton and Bush, both great friends of Israel, disagreed.
    They had the facts in front of them, you don’t.

  3. Naomi Litvin says:

    Dear Rabbi,
    Unfortunately, many American Jews are unaware of what you mean by knowing “the facts in the Pollard case.” If more mainstream orgs spoke up for freeing Jonathan Pollard, then more of the people that are too lazy to educate themselves would read http://www.jonathanpollard.org on the 25 + years and recent developments. I wholeheartedly support freeing this Jew who stood for us in protecting Israel against nuclear attack. I just we wish someone had stood for us during the Holocaust.
    The “facts of the case” to me, have more questions than answers. Like, what has motivated such fear of our presidents in not granting clemency to Pollard? They cannot come forth to say, because they are being controlled, perhaps by Arabian oil interests? This is beyond incredible, that the swirl of mystery still surrounds this case, and a man rots in prison for protecting Israel. What really blows my mind, though, are the people that are not coming forward to say #FreeJonathanPollard. I am so disappointed in my fellow Jews.

Leave a Reply to Phyllis Shapiro Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: